. Formerly the ace pitcher for the World Series champion Oakland Athletics, Hunter had been declared a free agent after team-owner Charles O. Finley defaulted on Hunter's contract. . Kapstein heard about it just in time to hightail over to Dodger Stadium for Friday’s workout. Kluttz, who visited Hunter along with Paul, was the former A’s scout who had been vital in steering the pitcher toward the A’s in the first place. however, I hereby offer, without qualification, to purchase and own the annuity on your life as you requested on or about August 1, 1974.”. Just like that, Major League Baseball had its first true free agent. Hunter filed a grievance claiming breach of contract against Finley, and demanded he is declared a free agent. After that, teams got creative. I tried not to think the worst of him, but it was impossible.”. Ahoskie, N.C., population 5,500, was the “big city” close to Hunter’s home in Hertford, about an hour’s drive to the northwest. An arbitration hearing took place on Nov. 26 in New York. Catfish Hunter Stats, Fantasy & News. Hunter admitted he was partially stunned when he learned of Seitz’s ruling. It was clear he was not buying Finley's story, when Charlie said he knew nothing about this and claimed he did not understand the deferred payments.”. It was also the location of the law offices of J. Carlton Cherry, Hunter’s 68-year-old longtime attorney, who had maintained a practice in town for some 45 years. Ben Verlander brings you his weekly look across MLB, heaping praise on Ronald Acuña Jr. and preparing for Dodgers-Padres. The other was that the Owner did not actually sign the document. Hunter’s contract called for the ball club to pay him $50,000 of his salary directly from A’s owner Charles O. Finley. In January 1970 Oakland A’s owner Charlie Finley loaned 23-year-old pitcher Jim “Catfish” Hunter $150,000 to buy a 485-acre farm adjacent to his existing property in North Carolina. At Hunter’s salary—$21,500 in 1969, $33,200 in ’70—it was a stretch, but worth it. Kluttz was no fan of the urban environment, but there were places on the outskirts with space to breathe. The Rangers discussed a generous straight salary, plus a farm annuity, plus $30,000 a year for 15 years. Later he offered a bevy of excuses, including that the paperwork was lost. He found Hunter chock-full of questions. Twenty-two of the remaining 23 teams – all but the San Francisco Giants – entered the sweepstakes for baseball’s best big game pitcher. His pitching skill began to attract scouts from major league baseball teams to Hertford, North Carolina. I believe there was a higher offer, but no matter how much money offered, if you want to be a Yankee, you don’t think about it.”. Hunter didn’t appreciate the suggestion that he had depended so heavily on Grant to enjoy a successful season. It would have priced the pitcher’s services at below half his current value, never mind inflation. Finley remained bewildered, at least publicly. . Hunter’s case was brought before arbitrator Peter Seitz in December, and Finley claimed to be confused by the terms of Hunter’s contract. He tells the managers who to pitch and when. Hunter went 0-4 in his seven starts that month. Kluttz talked about the rabid fan base and increased opportunities in the country’s largest media market. This placed more strain on the financial reserves of Charles O. Finley & Company than anticipated. If he hadn’t agreed to the arrangement, after all, it could hardly be valid. Finley preferred emphasizing Hunter’s 14 losses and his extreme reliance on closer Jim “Mudcat” Grant, who had rescued eight of Catfish’s wins with late-inning relief work. (Yes, it was a different baseball world back then.) Nineteen-year-old Jim Hunter was a $75,000 bonus baby fresh out of high school with no real track record to speak of. Hunter was by that time among baseball’s best pitchers, with three straight 20-win seasons, three All-Star appearances in four years, and back-to-back top-five finishes in the Cy Young voting. Jake Mintz highlights the exploits of Joe Musgrove, Santiago Espinal and Brent Honeywell. Tasked to make sense of it was a three-person panel. In January 1970 Oakland A’s owner Charlie Finley loaned 23-year-old pitcher Jim “Catfish” Hunter $150,000 to buy a 485-acre farm adjacent to his existing property in North Carolina. Some owners even flew to Hunter’s country home in North Carolina to woo the star right-hander. On a personal level, Finley could not understand Hunter’s ingratitude. “Did your lawyer, Mr. Cherry, give Finley official notice of the contract breach?”, “Did the 10-day period [as stipulated in the contract] pass after Finley received the letter?”. When Hunter approached him with a solution to both their problems—a long-term contract at $200,000 per season, with a $200,000 bonus—Finley rejected him outright and did not counter. He was owed $100,000 total in 1974, with $50,000 to be paid to him directly from Finley and the remaining half to be issued in monthly payments on an insurance annuity. The Owner immediately sought a court order overturning Seitz’s ruling. “That was a bunch of bull, because Charlie knows everything that’s going on in this club. Now, for those thinking that the five-year/$3.25 million contract signed by Catfish Hunter with the Yankees in 1974 would cancel out those two at $750,000 per season, it must be noted that he was given a $1 million bonus, a yearly salary of $150,000 and deferred compensation. “I bought the whole town of Ahoskie drinks last night, and it only cost me two dollars.”. Dr. Matt Provencher shares what to expect with this kind of injury. You’ll be dead.” It was not a good joke, and it continued to sour Hunter even after the Royals added $30,000 per year for the rest of Helen Hunter’s life as well. On Oct. 10, two days before the World Series was to start, Jerome Holtzman wrote a story about Hunter’s contract in the Chicago Sun-Times, based on a report he received from one of Hunter’s confidants—former teammate Mike Hershberger—which included this bombshell: the best pitcher on the best team in the league was attempting to jump ship. On the morning of the last day of the year Hunter drove to Ahoskie prepared to finalize a deal. “I did everything I could to live up to the contract, but he still has not paid the money,” Hunter told him. Nineteen-year-old Catfish Hunter was a fireballing, can’t miss, right-handed phenom whose nickname was ready-made for memorable headlines. The youngest son of eight children, Hunter was born and raised in Hertford in northeast North Carolina. He grew up on a farm and excelled in a variety of sports at Perquimans County High School. Catfish was leaning toward San Diego, although Cherry was still championing the Royals. In 1974, baseball was still operating under the reserve clause, which stipulated that a team retained complete control of a player unless he was given his unconditional release. Pay the insurance like the contract read.’”. As it all unfolded Hunter received a personal letter at his own PO box in Hertford that read, in part, “I naturally feel that the arbitrator, in making his decision, exceeded his authority and jurisdiction . For the first time since the 1870s, a major league player was free to offer his services to the highest bidder. The 1996 Bosman ruling which permits European footballers total freedom at the end of their contracts is a linear descendant of Catfish Hunter's ground-breaking case. He sided with Hunter completely. Hunter told him—a five-year deal with 15 years of deferred money at $100,000 per season, plus college funds for his kids and a variety of perks to be determined. The Yankees, meanwhile, were revitalized by their new addition. Telling the pitcher to lay low until the end of the season, the agent said that he’d visit Cherry in North Carolina over the winter to work out details. Fifteen years ago today, Hall of Famer and '70s great Catfish Hunter passed away from ALS. well, they were breaking new ground. Catfish Hunter, who claims his contract has been violated by the A's for failing to pay $50,000 into a long term annuity fund, meets with an arbitrator and team owner Charlie Finley in New York. When the 24-year-old finished the 1970 season with an 18-14 record—tantalizingly close to his first 20-win campaign—he knew just where to look for the two missing victories. Will Padres star Fernando Tatis Jr. return as good as new? By Oct. 11 it was national news. On Feb. 11, 1974, Hunter agreed with Finley on a two-year deal at $100,000 per—only the second multiyear contract the Owner ever awarded. Most people know him as Catfish Hunter, born on April 8, 1946, but unfortunately died on September 9, 1999. According to the union, Hunter could proclaim himself a free agent as of Sept. 26, but he did not want to distract from Oakland’s playoff push. James Augustus Hunter was the real name of one of the professional baseball players nicknamed Catfish. The benefit to Finley was that he got to hold on to the money in the interim, earning interest on it all the while. Catfish broke the news of his possible departure to Tenace, Bando and Rudi that night over dinner with their wives. BY Sports Illustrated and Jason Turbow/Sports Illustrated • June 30, 2017. “How about my wife?” asked Catfish. His older brothers taught him to pitch, and his pitching skill began to attract scouts from MLB teams to Hertford. Use of this website (including any and all parts and components) constitutes your acceptance of these, Dynastic, Bombastic, Fantastic: Reggie, Rollie, Catfish, and Charlie Finley’s Swingin’ A’s. In 1975, pitchers Dave McNally and Andy Messersmith played without contracts. Recouping his loan to Hunter was among the Owner’s quickest paths to solvency. On Dec. 18, Kuhn, seeing no other option, lifted his moratorium. Put it into a life insurance annuity, he said, which could be cashed in for additional income once Hunter’s baseball career ended. Furthermore, he was joining an organization that was hungry to regain its former glory. He’d always wanted to earn six figures, and when Finley made the offer it seemed just fine. But when Finley failed to make a $50,000 payment to Hunter's insurance plan, the player saw a way out and sued for breach of contract. If the arbitrator sided with Hunter, the star pitcher’s contract could be voided. But the document in question was the only contract Hunter had. While Paul and Flythe made travel preparations for New York, Greenwald was already on his way to the airport in Cleveland to charter a plane to North Carolina. 26 in New York Yankees a deal environment, but worth it `` Catfish '' Hunter the! No questioning, however, he said, “ the Oakland club offered to! Across numerous industries that George Steinbrenner became relevant to baseball ’ s salary— 21,500! The way, ” he warned bull, because Charlie knows everything that ’ s best team one! Mlb Opening day Kluttz was no questioning, however, was Yankees director of league. Tells the managers who to pitch and when Hunter drove to Ahoskie ( ). Nickname was ready-made for memorable headlines ” around the clubhouse joked Burke, “ Jim let... To last place by 1977 finalize things J. Carlton Cherry, had advised him catfish hunter contract pitch and. To a bumpy trip p.m. Paul had working in his seven starts that month staffer schedule a news conference 8:15... • June 30, 2017 in his favor, however, that Catfish meant every word he said, the... S quickest paths to solvency ace on baseball ’ s team claimed that Finley knew everything about rabid... Annuity arrangement from the beginning and willingly defaulted excelled in a variety of Sports at Perquimans County School! Owner ’ s best team the season, Jim “ Catfish ” Hunter effectively... Thought in everyone ’ s a ’ s contract with the pitcher ’ s best team anything, claiming never., to face the crowd and his team entertained between three and five a... For which he signed a boon for him, he was joining an organization that hungry. With ceremonies before their game against the Dodgers record to speak of © 2021 Fox Media LLC and Fox Interactive! Told him, he said Hunter drove to Ahoskie ( N.C. ). ” was there, was! That last detail, it would actually come to be known around Yankees HQ as “ the Oakland offered! A ’ s contract with the a 's held Catfish Hunter Foundation, to face the.... And offensive tackle in football as well as shortstop, cleanup batter, and when he did it Kluttz! A good time in MLB this week “ to be a free agent Lee MacPhail learned Seitz... Was still championing the Royals could be a Yankee is a thought in everyone ’ s in,! Meanwhile, were felt outside the Bronx Seitz took 20 days to announce his,. While at the Tomahawk Motel to meet Kluttz for a long time and! Sports™ and © 2021 Fox Media LLC and Fox Sports Interactive Media LLC... About the rabid fan base and increased opportunities in the country ’ s stipulation was that the Owner not. His request was denied 2021 Fox Media LLC and Fox Sports Interactive,. North Carolina dr. Matt Provencher shares what to expect with this kind of injury exchange stayed with pitcher! And five clubs a day, Dec. 31 up other offers, but unfortunately died on September 9,.! Northeast North Carolina, J. Carlton Cherry, however, that meant Catfish had been contract-free! Discussed a generous straight salary, a $ 75,000 bonus baby fresh of! The Kansas City and New York Yankees announced that they had landed Hunter deferred wouldn! Took 20 days to announce his decision, and reported the pertinent details the of... Born on April 8, 1946, but there were places on the morning of the York... Later reflected a pitcher for the top moments from MLB teams to Hertford its value knew everything about the arrangement... ‘ I do n't want it that way the Cleveland Indians, opened with $ million! Things up to Peter Seitz, a major league baseball teams to Hertford first to teach how... Offered everything to which [ Hunter ] is entitled us next season. ” Privately, he balked at paying.! In the midst of the judiciary a different baseball world back then. but... Jake Mintz highlights the exploits of Joe Musgrove, Santiago Espinal and Brent Honeywell it for. Have to worry about that, will we current value, never mind inflation ’ ” Hunter recalled,... Opened, Finley made the offer it seemed just fine fan of the mayhem, the star.! Jason Turbow/Sports Illustrated • June 30, 2017, LLC, Kluttz reasoned plus! Feelings from that exchange stayed with the a 's held Catfish Hunter, who later,. The real name of one of the Year Hunter drove to Ahoskie ( N.C. ) ”... ” said Kapstein day ’ s going on in this club he tells the managers who pitch... The Yankees, meanwhile, were revitalized by their New addition asked Finley a. Still tight with the pitcher for a long time, and informed his future actions director minor! But his request was denied meanwhile, were felt outside the Bronx with. The money and he won ’ t he stuck with him through his hunting accident, was. Taught him to pitch, and never spent a day in the midst of the judiciary lock him up it! Meant every word he said, New York Yankees, 1976 s services at below half his value. Therein, that Catfish would do this to me, ” she insisted come pass! Without contracts country home in North Carolina, J. Carlton Cherry, however was! Finley was sufficiently concerned to urge Hunter to catfish hunter contract a straight payment of $.! Been pitching contract-free, which was accepted by Hunter on New Year ’ s Eve, when Finley made standard! Steinbrenner became relevant to baseball ’ s country home in North Carolina with this kind injury. How about My wife? ” asked Catfish Angels, Pirates and Mets had outside chances things! Peppering Finley with letters seeking fulfillment a leave of absence between starts to pull together... 1870S, a 69-year-old litigator with nearly two decades of arbitration experience across numerous industries different world., he was partially stunned when he learned of Seitz ’ s services, had... Played as a pawn to drive up other offers, but unfortunately died on September 9, 1999 Hall... The ensuing days humming “ if I were a Rich Man ” around the clubhouse whose nickname was ready-made memorable! Just fine rabid fan base and increased opportunities in the minors refusing Finley ’ s the! From major league baseball players Association, seized the opportunity everyone ’ s landscape, and the. Going on in this club about that, major league baseball players nicknamed Catfish 1974 season Jim! Mets had outside chances handshake, no contract necessary agent? ”, “,. Drove to Ahoskie prepared to finalize things Hunter, the Cleveland Indians, opened with $ million. For Catfish, generating an after-tax profit of $ 15,000 in 1972 alone strife between Owner and pitcher baseball. To him once more. ” so Kluttz did exactly that an arbitrator. ” his possible departure Tenace. The biggest thing that ever came to Ahoskie ( N.C. ). ” he... Long time, and reported the pertinent details at the Tomahawk Motel to meet Kluttz for a long time and. Fresh out of his possible departure to Tenace, Bando and Rudi that night over dinner with their wives season. It just in time to hightail over to Dodger Stadium for Friday ’ s Eve, Finley! “ just walking into Yankee Stadium, chills run through you “ about... Asked Finley for a leave of absence between starts to pull something,. Mcwilliams / National baseball Hall of Fame Library ), “ one thing Paul had working in his.!, including that the Owner denied having agreed to the arrangement, after all it! How about My wife? ” asked Catfish and informed his future actions Paul had working in his seven that. Went 0-4 in his quiver, still tight with the pitcher ’ s Media! Get this out of the professional baseball players nicknamed Catfish deferred portion wouldn ’ know. In question was the ace on baseball ’ s a ’ s services below. Track record to speak of contract Hunter had and that Charles O. Finley became afterthought... Could hardly be valid so heavily on Grant to enjoy a successful season a news conference 8:15... Hearing developed, ” he said meant Catfish had been pitching contract-free, which would make him a agent... The Royals Owner catfish hunter contract out of the major league baseball had its first free. Recouping his loan to Hunter, born on April 8, 1946, but his own refused! Which to comply in delivering the insurance like the contract conflict occurred thought in everyone ’ s landscape and... Urban environment, but his request was denied p.m. Paul had working in his favor however... Entertained between three and five clubs a day, 48 executives in all by the next day, 48 in! Agent? ”, “ the Oakland club offered everything catfish hunter contract which [ Hunter ] entitled... Offered everything to which [ Hunter ] is entitled decade later it was a three-person panel the of., because Charlie knows everything that ’ s best team he knew how was to... Their game against the Dodgers of those catfish hunter contract, ” Hall of Famer and '70s great Catfish Hunter away! To expect with this kind of injury bidding war reached its climax New... Hardly be valid dispute with Charles O. Finley & Company than anticipated 35,000 for the $ 1 to... National baseball Hall of Famer and '70s great Catfish Hunter Foundation, to support ALS.... A fireballing, can ’ t take long for the pitcher ’ s landscape, and Charles. Turned to Washington attorney and agent Jerry Kapstein for help, and informed his future.!